Influencer marketing & fashion industry – The legal implications

Introduction

In recent years, the Indian fashion industry has witnessed a significant increase in influencer marketing. With the rise of social media platforms like Instagram and TikTok, fashion influencers in India have amassed massive followings and have become the go-to source for fashion trends and product recommendations. However, with the growth of influencer marketing, there are also growing concerns about the legal implications of this marketing strategy.

Consider the following scenario: A popular fashion influencer in India posts a picture on Instagram wearing a dress from a particular brand. The post generates a lot of engagement and leads to a surge in sales for the brand. However, the followers do not know that the influencer was paid to promote the dress and that the post was sponsored content. This lack of transparency raises questions about the legality of influencer marketing in India and whether brands are following the rules and regulations surrounding it.

This article will provide an analytical perspective on the legal issues surrounding influencer marketing in the Indian fashion industry, including the importance of disclosure and potential legal consequences for brands and influencers. By understanding the legal implications of influencer marketing, brands and influencers can ensure they comply with the relevant regulations and protect themselves from legal liability.

Disclosure and Transparency Requirements

Influencer marketing relies on the trust and credibility built between the influencer and their followers. Therefore, transparency and disclosure are critical in ensuring that consumers are not misled or deceived by sponsored content. In India, the Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) has established guidelines for influencer marketing, which require influencers to disclose sponsored content. This includes posts or videos that promote a brand or product that the influencer has received compensation for, such as free products, payment, or discounts.

The disclosure must be clear, prominent, and upfront, so that followers can easily understand that the post is sponsored content. The guidelines recommend using labels like “#ad” or “#sponsored” in the post caption on social media platforms like Instagram. Alternatively, influencers can use the ‘paid partnership’ feature on social media platforms like Instagram, which allows them to disclose their financial relationship with the brand without compromising the aesthetics of the post. In addition, influencers should avoid making any claims that are not supported by evidence, misleading or false, which may violate advertising standards and result in legal consequences.

Failure to comply with disclosure and transparency requirements can lead to legal consequences for both the influencer and the brand. For instance, influencers who fail to disclose sponsored content may be fined or face legal action for deceptive advertising practices. Brands may also face legal consequences if they are found to be complicit in misleading consumers, such as facing fines, legal action, or damage to their reputation.

Therefore, it is essential for both influencers and brands to ensure that they comply with the disclosure and transparency requirements established by the ASCI to avoid legal liabilities and maintain the trust of their followers. By doing so, they can build a strong and sustainable relationship with their audience and avoid any negative legal implications.

Addressing Sexual Offenses: Promoting Justice and Equality

Intellectual Property Issues

Influencer marketing in the fashion industry often involves the use of copyrighted materials, such as photographs and videos, which can raise intellectual property issues. Brands and influencers need to ensure that they obtain proper permissions or licenses before using such materials to avoid infringing on the rights of others.

For instance, a fashion brand may commission an influencer to create content featuring their products, which may include using a photograph taken by a professional photographer. However, the brand and influencer need to obtain the necessary rights to use the photograph, either through obtaining permission from the photographer or obtaining a license to use the photograph.

Obtaining permission or a license for the use of copyrighted materials is essential in influencer marketing. It is important for both the influencer and the brand to ensure that they have the legal right to use any photographs or videos before incorporating them into any sponsored content. Failure to do so can lead to legal issues and reputational damage for both parties involved.

Similarly, trademarks play an important role in influencer marketing as brands often use their trademarks as a way to distinguish their products and services from those of others. Influencers need to avoid using trademarks in a way that may cause confusion among consumers or create a false association with the brand.

For example, an influencer may feature a product in their post with a logo that is similar to the trademark of another brand. This may create confusion among consumers or may even be seen as a deliberate attempt to associate their product with the other brand, which can lead to trademark infringement.

To avoid intellectual property issues in influencer marketing, it is important to follow proper procedures for obtaining permission or licenses to use any copyrighted materials or trademarks. Brands and Influencers should ensure that they have the legal right to use any materials incorporated into sponsored content. Similarly, influencers should take measures to ensure that they have the right to use any materials that they incorporate into their content.

Contracts and Agreements

Influencer marketing in the fashion industry involves a variety of legal agreements between the parties involved, including influencer contracts, agency contracts, and brand agreements. These agreements outline the terms and conditions of the relationship between the influencer, agency, and brand, and set out the legal rights and obligations of each party.

The influencer contract is perhaps the most important agreement in influencer marketing as it sets out the terms of the influencer’s engagement with the brand. This agreement typically outlines the scope of work, the payment terms, the duration of the engagement, and the rights and obligations of both the influencer and the brand. It is important for both parties to understand and agree upon these terms before entering into the engagement to avoid any misunderstandings or legal disputes down the line.

Similarly, agency contracts are agreements between the agency and the brand. These contracts outline the agency’s responsibilities, the scope of services provided, the payment terms, and any specific performance requirements. Agency contracts may also outline the expectations for influencer selection and how influencers are contracted and managed.

Brand agreements are contracts between the brand and the influencer. These agreements set out the details of the sponsored content and its publication. The brand has the responsibility to disclose that the content is sponsored, while the influencer has the responsibility to adhere to the brand’s guidelines regarding the content’s creation, publication, and promotion.

When drafting these legal agreements, it is essential to ensure that all parties’ interests are protected. Key terms and provisions that should be included in such agreements include payment terms, termination clauses, confidentiality provisions, intellectual property rights, exclusivity clauses, non-disclosure agreements, and any warranties or representations.

Failure to include these terms and provisions in agreements could lead to various legal disputes, such as breach of contract, intellectual property infringement, and more. Therefore, it is vital to ensure that the agreements comply with relevant laws and regulations and adequately protect the interests of all parties involved. The legal agreements involved in influencer marketing in the fashion industry are essential to ensure that all parties’ interests are protected, and the terms of the engagement are clear. Properly drafted agreements with key provisions and terms can help avoid misunderstandings, disputes, and legal issues down the line.

Liability and Risk Management

Influencer marketing can present several legal risks and liabilities for fashion brands that engage in it. One major area of concern is false advertising, where influencers make claims about a product that are not true or accurate. This can lead to consumer harm, and brands can be held liable for such actions[i]. Another area of concern is defamation, where influencers may make false or damaging statements about competitors or other parties. This can result in lawsuits and other legal action.

Privacy violations are also a concern in influencer marketing, as influencers may inadvertently or intentionally disclose personal information about individuals, such as their location or identity, without their consent. This can result in legal action and reputational damage for the brand.[ii]

To mitigate these risks, fashion brands should take a proactive approach to influencer vetting and monitoring. This includes carefully selecting influencers who have a good reputation and align with the brand’s values and ethics. Brands should also ensure that influencers disclose sponsored content and adhere to all legal and regulatory requirements.

Contracts and agreements with influencers and agencies should also include provisions that address liability and risk management. This includes indemnification clauses, limitation of liability clauses, and confidentiality provisions. Brands should also monitor influencer content regularly and have a plan in place for addressing any legal issues that may arise.

While influencer marketing can be a valuable tool for fashion brands, it also presents several legal risks and liabilities. To manage these risks effectively, brands must take a proactive approach to influencer vetting, monitoring, and contract negotiations. By doing so, they can protect themselves from legal action and maintain a positive reputation in the market.

India as an Arbitration Hub: A Distant Reality

Conclusion

In conclusion, influencer marketing has become an important part of the fashion industry, and brands must be aware of the legal implications surrounding it. The lack of transparency in sponsored posts, the use of copyrighted materials, the importance of contracts and agreements, and potential liability and risk management are all issues that must be addressed by brands and their legal teams.

To mitigate the risks associated with influencer marketing, brands should prioritize transparency by ensuring that sponsored content is clearly disclosed, obtaining permission or licenses for the use of copyrighted materials, and carefully vetting influencers to avoid liability for false advertising, defamation, or privacy violations. Additionally, brands should consider using social media monitoring tools to ensure that influencers are complying with the terms of their agreements and the regulations set forth by governing bodies.

Based on the legal implications of influencer marketing in the fashion industry discussed above, there are some recommendations and unique solutions that fashion brands can implement to avoid legal issues and protect their reputation:

1. Provide clear and conspicuous disclosures: Brands should ensure that all influencer posts are clearly labeled as sponsored content. This can be done by using hashtags such as #ad, #sponsored, or #partner, or by including a disclosure statement in the caption of the post. Brands should also require influencers to disclose their relationships with the brand in their bios or profiles.
2. Implement a thorough vetting process: Before partnering with an influencer, brands should conduct a thorough background check to ensure that the influencer has a positive reputation and does not have a history of engaging in unethical or illegal practices. Brands should also ensure that the influencer has the necessary expertise and experience to promote the brand effectively.
3. Monitor influencer content: Brands should regularly monitor the content that their influencers post to ensure that it complies with the law and brand guidelines. This can be done through the use of content management tools or by hiring a third-party agency to monitor the content on behalf of the brand.
4. Draft comprehensive contracts: Brands should draft comprehensive influencer contracts that clearly outline the expectations and obligations of both parties. These contracts should also include provisions that address intellectual property issues, disclosure requirements, and potential liabilities.
5. Educate influencers on legal compliance: Brands should provide their influencers with training and resources on legal compliance and best practices for influencer marketing. This can include webinars, workshops, or written guidelines.

By implementing these recommendations and unique solutions, fashion brands can minimize their legal risks and build stronger relationships with their influencers and audiences. Overall, influencer marketing presents both challenges and opportunities for fashion brands and their legal teams. By staying informed about the legal implications and taking proactive steps to mitigate risks, brands can successfully navigate the complex world of influencer marketing and leverage its power to reach new audiences and drive sales.

This article is authored by Arghya Sen, student at Amity university, Kolkata

[i] Laxmi Mohan Kumar, Govt Releases Guidelines For Social Media Influencers; False Advertisement Can Now Attract Up To Rs 50 Lakh Fine, (Jan. 21, 2023), https://thelogicalindian.com/trending/social-media-influencers-false-advertisement-can-bring-fine-of-rs-50-lakh-39997.

[ii] JAMES DAVIES, Roster,Breaking Down Influencer Marketing, Data and Privacy

 (JAN 12, 2023)https://www.getroster.com/blog/third-party-data/.